diff --git a/Telegram/SourceFiles/ayu/ayu_settings.cpp b/Telegram/SourceFiles/ayu/ayu_settings.cpp
index db31341548..f06ba4d2e1 100644
--- a/Telegram/SourceFiles/ayu/ayu_settings.cpp
+++ b/Telegram/SourceFiles/ayu/ayu_settings.cpp
@@ -109,7 +109,20 @@ void GhostModeAccountSettings::setUseScheduledMessages(bool val) {
 	AyuSettings::save();
 }
 
-void GhostModeAccountSettings::setSendWithoutSound(bool val) {
+bool GhostModeAccountSettings::shouldSendWithoutSound() const {
+	switch (_sendWithoutSound.current()) {
+	case SendWithoutSoundOption::Never:
+		return false;
+	case SendWithoutSoundOption::InGhostMode:
+		return isGhostModeActive();
+	case SendWithoutSoundOption::Always:
+		return true;
+	}
+	Unexpected("Value in GhostModeAccountSettings::shouldSendWithoutSound.");
+}
+
+void GhostModeAccountSettings::setSendWithoutSound(
+		SendWithoutSoundOption val) {
 	if (_sendWithoutSound.current() == val) return;
 	_sendWithoutSound = val;
 	AyuSettings::save();
@@ -195,7 +208,14 @@ void from_json(const nlohmann::json &j, GhostModeAccountSettings &s) {
 	s._sendOfflinePacketAfterOnline = j.value("sendOfflinePacketAfterOnline", false);
 	s._markReadAfterAction = j.value("markReadAfterAction", true);
 	s._useScheduledMessages = j.value("useScheduledMessages", false);
-	s._sendWithoutSound = j.value("sendWithoutSound", false);
+	const auto sendWithoutSound = j.find("sendWithoutSound");
+	s._sendWithoutSound = (sendWithoutSound == j.end())
+		? SendWithoutSoundOption::Never
+		: sendWithoutSound->is_boolean()
+		? (sendWithoutSound->get<bool>()
+			? SendWithoutSoundOption::Always
+			: SendWithoutSoundOption::Never)
+		: sendWithoutSound->get<SendWithoutSoundOption>();
 	s._suggestGhostModeBeforeViewingStory = j.value("suggestGhostModeBeforeViewingStory", true);
 	s._sendReadMessagesLocked = j.value("sendReadMessagesLocked", false);
 	s._sendReadStoriesLocked = j.value("sendReadStoriesLocked", false);
diff --git a/Telegram/SourceFiles/ayu/ayu_settings.h b/Telegram/SourceFiles/ayu/ayu_settings.h
index 6906a1ad60..29f131149a 100644
--- a/Telegram/SourceFiles/ayu/ayu_settings.h
+++ b/Telegram/SourceFiles/ayu/ayu_settings.h
@@ -45,6 +45,12 @@ enum class TranslationProvider {
 	Native = 3,
 };
 
+enum class SendWithoutSoundOption {
+	Never = 0,
+	InGhostMode = 1,
+	Always = 2,
+};
+
 NLOHMANN_JSON_SERIALIZE_ENUM(PeerIdDisplay, {
 	{PeerIdDisplay::Hidden, 0},
 	{PeerIdDisplay::TelegramApi, 1},
@@ -70,6 +76,12 @@ NLOHMANN_JSON_SERIALIZE_ENUM(TranslationProvider, {
 	{TranslationProvider::Native, "native"},
 })
 
+NLOHMANN_JSON_SERIALIZE_ENUM(SendWithoutSoundOption, {
+	{SendWithoutSoundOption::Never, 0},
+	{SendWithoutSoundOption::InGhostMode, 1},
+	{SendWithoutSoundOption::Always, 2},
+})
+
 class GhostModeAccountSettings {
 public:
 	GhostModeAccountSettings();
@@ -81,7 +93,8 @@ public:
 	[[nodiscard]] bool sendOfflinePacketAfterOnline() const { return _sendOfflinePacketAfterOnline.current(); }
 	[[nodiscard]] bool markReadAfterAction() const { return _markReadAfterAction.current(); }
 	[[nodiscard]] bool useScheduledMessages() const { return _useScheduledMessages.current(); }
-	[[nodiscard]] bool sendWithoutSound() const { return _sendWithoutSound.current(); }
+	[[nodiscard]] SendWithoutSoundOption sendWithoutSound() const { return _sendWithoutSound.current(); }
+	[[nodiscard]] bool shouldSendWithoutSound() const;
 	[[nodiscard]] bool suggestGhostModeBeforeViewingStory() const { return _suggestGhostModeBeforeViewingStory.current(); }
 	[[nodiscard]] bool isGhostModeActive() const { return _ghostModeActive.current(); }
 	[[nodiscard]] bool isUseScheduledMessages() const { return isGhostModeActive() && useScheduledMessages(); }
@@ -99,7 +112,7 @@ public:
 	void setSendOfflinePacketAfterOnline(bool val);
 	void setMarkReadAfterAction(bool val);
 	void setUseScheduledMessages(bool val);
-	void setSendWithoutSound(bool val);
+	void setSendWithoutSound(SendWithoutSoundOption val);
 	void setSuggestGhostModeBeforeViewingStory(bool val);
 	void setGhostModeEnabled(bool val);
 
@@ -123,8 +136,8 @@ public:
 	[[nodiscard]] rpl::producer<bool> markReadAfterActionChanges() const { return _markReadAfterAction.changes(); }
 	[[nodiscard]] rpl::producer<bool> useScheduledMessagesValue() const { return _useScheduledMessages.value(); }
 	[[nodiscard]] rpl::producer<bool> useScheduledMessagesChanges() const { return _useScheduledMessages.changes(); }
-	[[nodiscard]] rpl::producer<bool> sendWithoutSoundValue() const { return _sendWithoutSound.value(); }
-	[[nodiscard]] rpl::producer<bool> sendWithoutSoundChanges() const { return _sendWithoutSound.changes(); }
+	[[nodiscard]] rpl::producer<SendWithoutSoundOption> sendWithoutSoundValue() const { return _sendWithoutSound.value(); }
+	[[nodiscard]] rpl::producer<SendWithoutSoundOption> sendWithoutSoundChanges() const { return _sendWithoutSound.changes(); }
 	[[nodiscard]] rpl::producer<bool> suggestGhostModeBeforeViewingStoryValue() const { return _suggestGhostModeBeforeViewingStory.value(); }
 	[[nodiscard]] rpl::producer<bool> suggestGhostModeBeforeViewingStoryChanges() const { return _suggestGhostModeBeforeViewingStory.changes(); }
 	[[nodiscard]] rpl::producer<bool> ghostModeActiveValue() const { return _ghostModeActive.value(); }
@@ -154,7 +167,7 @@ private:
 	rpl::variable<bool> _sendOfflinePacketAfterOnline = false;
 	rpl::variable<bool> _markReadAfterAction = true;
 	rpl::variable<bool> _useScheduledMessages = false;
-	rpl::variable<bool> _sendWithoutSound = false;
+	rpl::variable<SendWithoutSoundOption> _sendWithoutSound = SendWithoutSoundOption::Never;
 	rpl::variable<bool> _suggestGhostModeBeforeViewingStory = true;
 	rpl::variable<bool> _ghostModeActive = false;
 
diff --git a/Telegram/SourceFiles/ayu/ui/settings/settings_ayu.cpp b/Telegram/SourceFiles/ayu/ui/settings/settings_ayu.cpp
index 8a85c73ec6..7b29799643 100644
--- a/Telegram/SourceFiles/ayu/ui/settings/settings_ayu.cpp
+++ b/Telegram/SourceFiles/ayu/ui/settings/settings_ayu.cpp
@@ -27,6 +27,7 @@
 #include "styles/style_menu_icons.h"
 #include "styles/style_settings.h"
 #include "ui/painter.h"
+#include "ui/boxes/single_choice_box.h"
 #include "ui/vertical_list.h"
 #include "ui/text/text.h"
 #include "ui/toast/toast.h"
@@ -445,31 +446,45 @@ void BuildGhostEssentials(SectionBuilder &builder) {
 			AddDividerText(container, tr::ayu_UseScheduledMessagesDescription());
 
 			AddSkip(container);
-			const auto silentButton = AddButtonWithIcon(
+			const auto silentOptions = std::vector<QString>{
+				tr::ayu_SendWithoutSoundByDefaultNever(tr::now),
+				tr::ayu_SendWithoutSoundByDefaultInGhostMode(tr::now),
+				tr::ayu_SendWithoutSoundByDefaultAlways(tr::now),
+			};
+			const auto silentOptionText = state->selectedUserId.value(
+			) | rpl::map([=](uint64 id) {
+				return AyuSettings::ghost(id).sendWithoutSoundValue(
+				) | rpl::map([=](SendWithoutSoundOption value) {
+					return silentOptions[static_cast<int>(value)];
+				});
+			}) | rpl::flatten_latest();
+			const auto silentButton = AddButtonWithLabel(
 				container,
 				tr::ayu_SendWithoutSoundByDefault(),
-				st::settingsButtonNoIcon
-			);
+				std::move(silentOptionText),
+				st::settingsButtonNoIcon);
 			if (wctx.highlights) {
 				wctx.highlights->push_back(std::make_pair(
 					u"ayu/sendWithoutSound"_q,
 					HighlightEntry{ silentButton.get(), {} }));
 			}
-			silentButton->toggleOn(
-				state->selectedUserId.value()
-				| rpl::map([](uint64 id) {
-					return AyuSettings::ghost(id).sendWithoutSoundValue();
-				}) | rpl::flatten_latest()
-			)->toggledValue(
-			) | rpl::filter(
-				[=](bool enabled) {
-					return enabled != AyuSettings::ghost(state->selectedUserId.current()).sendWithoutSound();
-				}
-			) | on_next(
-				[=](bool enabled) {
-					AyuSettings::ghost(state->selectedUserId.current()).setSendWithoutSound(enabled);
-				},
-				container->lifetime());
+			silentButton->addClickHandler([=] {
+				controller->show(Box([=](not_null<Ui::GenericBox*> box) {
+					const auto save = [=](int index) {
+						AyuSettings::ghost(state->selectedUserId.current()
+						).setSendWithoutSound(
+							static_cast<SendWithoutSoundOption>(index));
+					};
+					SingleChoiceBox(box, {
+						.title = tr::ayu_SendWithoutSoundByDefault(),
+						.options = silentOptions,
+						.initialSelection = static_cast<int>(
+							AyuSettings::ghost(state->selectedUserId.current()
+							).sendWithoutSound()),
+						.callback = save,
+					});
+				}));
+			});
 			AddSkip(container);
 			AddDividerText(container, tr::ayu_SendWithoutSoundByDefaultDescription());
 
diff --git a/Telegram/SourceFiles/history/history_item_helpers.cpp b/Telegram/SourceFiles/history/history_item_helpers.cpp
index 132b12177f..21c158039b 100644
--- a/Telegram/SourceFiles/history/history_item_helpers.cpp
+++ b/Telegram/SourceFiles/history/history_item_helpers.cpp
@@ -614,7 +614,7 @@ bool ShouldSendSilent(
 		not_null<PeerData*> peer,
 		const Api::SendOptions &options) {
 	const auto &ghost = AyuSettings::ghost(&peer->session());
-	if (ghost.sendWithoutSound()) {
+	if (ghost.shouldSendWithoutSound()) {
 		return !options.silent;
 	}
 
diff --git a/Telegram/SourceFiles/menu/menu_send.cpp b/Telegram/SourceFiles/menu/menu_send.cpp
index ca96fffbb7..3f180e24c8 100644
--- a/Telegram/SourceFiles/menu/menu_send.cpp
+++ b/Telegram/SourceFiles/menu/menu_send.cpp
@@ -749,7 +749,7 @@ FillMenuResult FillSendMenu(
 		const auto &ghost = maybeShow
 			? AyuSettings::ghost(&maybeShow->session())
 			: AyuSettings::ghost();
-		const auto sendWithoutSound = ghost.sendWithoutSound();
+		const auto sendWithoutSound = ghost.shouldSendWithoutSound();
 		menu->addAction(
 			sendWithoutSound ? tr::ayu_SendWithSound(tr::now) : tr::lng_send_silent_message(tr::now),
 			[=] { action({ Api::SendOptions{ .silent = true } }, details); },
diff --git a/Telegram/SourceFiles/platform/mac/global_menu_mac.mm b/Telegram/SourceFiles/platform/mac/global_menu_mac.mm
index 68da50703a..2b9876d76b 100644
--- a/Telegram/SourceFiles/platform/mac/global_menu_mac.mm
+++ b/Telegram/SourceFiles/platform/mac/global_menu_mac.mm
@@ -105,7 +105,6 @@ private:
 	QAction *_ghostMode = nullptr;
 	QAction *_readOnInteract = nullptr;
 	QAction *_scheduleMessages = nullptr;
-	QAction *_sendWithoutSound = nullptr;
 
 	NSPasteboard *_pasteboard = nullptr;
 	int _pasteboardChangeCount = -1;
@@ -237,9 +236,6 @@ void Manager::retranslate() {
 	if (_scheduleMessages) {
 		_scheduleMessages->setText(tr::ayu_UseScheduledMessages(tr::now));
 	}
-	if (_sendWithoutSound) {
-		_sendWithoutSound->setText(tr::ayu_SendWithoutSoundByDefault(tr::now));
-	}
 }
 
 void Manager::ensureLanguageBound() {
@@ -336,7 +332,6 @@ void Manager::recomputeState() {
 	ForceDisabled(_ghostMode, ghostInactive);
 	ForceDisabled(_readOnInteract, ghostInactive);
 	ForceDisabled(_scheduleMessages, ghostInactive);
-	ForceDisabled(_sendWithoutSound, ghostInactive);
 	const auto setChecked = [](QAction *action, bool checked) {
 		const auto wasBlocked = action->blockSignals(true);
 		action->setChecked(checked);
@@ -348,12 +343,10 @@ void Manager::recomputeState() {
 			: tr::ayu_EnableGhostMode(tr::now));
 		setChecked(_readOnInteract, ghost->markReadAfterAction());
 		setChecked(_scheduleMessages, ghost->useScheduledMessages());
-		setChecked(_sendWithoutSound, ghost->sendWithoutSound());
 	} else {
 		_ghostMode->setText(tr::ayu_EnableGhostMode(tr::now));
 		setChecked(_readOnInteract, false);
 		setChecked(_scheduleMessages, false);
-		setChecked(_sendWithoutSound, false);
 	}
 }
 
@@ -592,13 +585,6 @@ void Manager::buildGhostModeMenu(QMenu *ghostMode) {
 			}
 		});
 
-	_sendWithoutSound = addToggle(
-		u"Send without Sound"_q,
-		[this](bool enabled) {
-			if (const auto ghost = resolveGhostSettings()) {
-				ghost->setSendWithoutSound(enabled);
-			}
-		});
 }
 
 void Manager::buildWindowMenu(QMenu *window) {
@@ -720,8 +706,7 @@ void Manager::destroy() {
 		= _strikeOut = _blockquote = _monospace = _clearFormat
 		= nullptr;
 	_ghostModeMenu = nullptr;
-	_ghostMode = _readOnInteract = _scheduleMessages = _sendWithoutSound
-		= nullptr;
+	_ghostMode = _readOnInteract = _scheduleMessages = nullptr;
 	_pasteboard = nullptr;
 	_pasteboardChangeCount = -1;
 	_pasteboardHasText = false;